Correspondence regarding the building of West College, 1803.
The following letters were written with regard to the construction of a new building at Dickinson College (West College) after the burning down of the previous structure, "New College."  The first letter is from Benjamin Latrobe and includes extensive comments on his design for the building.  The other two letters are from Hugh Henry Brackenridge to James Hamilton, both both of whom were members of the Board of Trustees who also served on the committee to arrange and coordinate the new building project.

Letter from Benjamin Latrobe to Hugh Henry Brackenridge
     May 18, 1803
Letter from Hugh Henry Brackenridge to James Hamilton
     May 19, 1803
Letter from Hugh Henry Brackenridge to James Hamilton
     May 22, 1803


[Editor's Note:  The following letters were written in May of 1803 with respect to the rebuilding of West College.  All subscripts, superscripts, strike-throughs, and misspellings have been retained.]




Benjamin Latrobe to Hugh Henry Brackenridge

Philadelphia, May 18th 1803. –
Dear Sir

    You will herewith receive the designs for Dickinson College which I promised you.  In forming them, I have endeavored to take all the circumstances which you stated to me into consideration, and to do the best for you which they would permit. – I will beg leave to state to you the principles which have governed me in the distribution, & arrangement of the apartments. –
    The two aspects, the most unpleasant in our climate are the North East & the North West.  The extreme cold of the North West winds in winter, & their dryness, which causes a rapid evaporation so thoroughly chills the walls of every house, expose to them, that when the wind, as is almost always the case, changes afterwards to the West & S.W. & becomes warmer & moister, – the water is precipated upon the Walls from the air, by their coldness, – as upon the outside of a Glass of cold Water in warm weather, – and they soon stream with humidity. – The North East winds bring along rain & sleet, – & their violence

drives the moisture into every wall of which the material will permit it. – The unpleasantness of the winds is aggravated by the rapidity suddenness with which the Northwest commonly succeeds the North East. – I have stated these things, which are indeed known to every body, to in order to explain a law, which is thereby imposed upon the Architecture of our Country: It is, – to reserve the Southern aspects of every building in the erection of which the choice is free, for the inhabited apartments, and to occupy the Northern aspects by communications, as Stairs, Lobbies, Halls, Vestibules etc.
    This Law governs the designs herewith presented to you.
    On the North are the Vestibule & Lobbies, or passages.  They protect the Southern rooms from the effect of the Northern winds.  On this Aspect I have also placed the dining room, a room only occasionally occupied for a short time, – & the School rooms above it, – which by means of Stoves, & the

concourse of Students are easily kept warm.  There are indeed two chambers in the N. E wing on each story. – If these chambers be inhabited by Preceptors, the one as a study, the other as a Bedchamber, the disadvantages of the Aspect must be overcome by such means, of Curtains & Carpets, as a Student does not so easily acquire.  The South ern Front affords on each story 6 rooms for Students.  The angle rooms will accomodate 3, and each of the other, 2 Students; in all 14 on each floor.
    The Hall is intended to occupy two stores.  Above the hall a room of equal size may be appropriated to a Library, or may furnish 4 or 6 Students rooms, 2 or 3 2 or 3 to the South and as many to the North. –
    The usual mode of planning colleges, by arranging the rooms on each side of a long passage, has many disadvantages, – the chief of which are the noise, & the necessary darkness of the Passage, and the bad aspect of one half of the rooms. – These inconveniences do not, I be-

lieve exist in the plan I present to you, & should at a future period, the celebrity of your institution encrease the number of your students, as it no doubt will, – it will be better to erect new accomodations, than to obtain room by connecting the wings, in order to save expense; as has often been done. –
    In respect to material, – I would, certainly, recommend that you should build of your your external walls of the lime stone of your Valley, rather than of brick.  The internal Walls, may with more advantage be built of brick. – It will be objected that limestone is so pervious to Water, that no Plaistering will stand upon it. – I do not know that it is more so than common brick, but it if were, I must observe, than no material whatsoever, unless the wall be 2f 6i thick will prevent the damp appearance of the Walls towards the North aspects, unless they be battened and plaistered upon Lath.  By battens are meant strips of 1½ inches thick fixed & about 2 inches wide

wide, which are fastened by Wall-hooks, upright to the Walls, at the distance of 15 inches from each other, & upon which laths are nailed as upon framed work.  No such precaution is necessary upon the internal walls.  The air thus enclosed between – Between the Plaistering upon Laths, & the Solid Wall [expunged and illegible] being a non conductor, prevents either, the Heat or the cold of the external wall from materially affecting the temperature of the room, and the Plaistering itself will always be dry. – This method has also the advantage that the plaistering of on the external Walls is easily made fair & straight, – whereas the roughness & irregularity of a Stone Wall is not easily got over by plaistering.
    I have said this much in order to give the Trustees an opportunity, – should they adopt the plan proposed, – of procured their principal materials at once. – But Should they contemplate to carry it into execution either with or without alteration, I shall expect that you

will have the goodness to appraise me of their resolution in the course of this month, that I may furnish such working plans as will be immediately necessary.–
    I beg leave also to suggest to you and to the Trustees, – that it will be impossible to conduct your building with success, oeconomy, & Satisfaction, unless some intelligent, experienced, & honest Man, – as superintendant of the Work, have controul over every part of it. – This situation is often given to some respectable, but superannuated Workman, from motives of benevolence.  Such a Superintendant is indeed adequate to the counting of bricks, the measurements of Stone and Lime, the keeping an account, & often to the decision on the quality of the materials & the goodness of Workmanship.  But these things though necessary, – are not all that are wanted.  The great & useful business of a Superintendant, – or as he is commonly called, a Clerk

of the Work, consists in so directing & combining the Labors of a variety of Workmen, that they shall all produce the building, without Loss of time or waste of material, or dispute among themselves, or disadvantage in the performance of their contracts, by want of material, or the necessity of waiting for each other.  Such an office requires vigor of mind & body, as well as mechanical knowledge & manual skill, and that whether you may meet with a person capable of filling it, the liberality or oeconomy of compensation will in part determine.  I do not think you will get a fit man under from 12 to 15 Dollars / Week. – We pay here 18$ Dollars at the public works.
    I beg to repeat what I before mentioned to you, – that as I conceive it to be the interest & duty of every good citizen to promote, – quoad virile, the education, and civilization of the Society in which he & his children are to live, I will with pleasure contribute to the reestablishment

of Dickinson college, every possible gratuitous personal assistance: – and should you accept of this part of contribution, – nothing will be charged against you, but such actual expenses as may arise in the course of my giving it to you.

                                        I am with true respect
                                             Yours truly
                                                    B Henry Latrobe
                                   Surveyor of the U. States buildings at Washington


Philadelphia
May 18th 1803

    I must request that you will excuse the evident marks of haste in this letter, which would have been more explanatory, had not the time to which you have limited me, been so short.



Hugh Henry Brackenridge to James Hamilton

           May 19. 1803.  Philada.
Sir.    From Easton on the delaware came with the speed of an express, to this city to wait with a view to see the celebrated Mr Latrobe who was said to be about to set out from this his place of residence & to be absent some time.  Had the good luck to find him at home, and having waited on him laid before him rough sketches of the several plans projected at Carlisle for Dickinson College; explained the Situation of the ground, and town, streets, etc. and probable fund for the building.
    Having left him near a week ago, and I have this afternoon again seen him, having in the mean time been from the city, at the Circuit Court of Bucks County.

He will forward by the mail addressed to you plans of the building to the best of his skill, & has delivered me a letter prepared in fact for the trustees, though addressed to me, explaining his ideas on the Subject.  The plan has been projected after much reflection on his part, with any assistance I could give as to collateral explanations & is fully approved of by me, if that is of any consequence or will contribute to Satisfy you as to the expediency of adopting it, in any degree.
    I write in haste but will be at home in [deleted and illegible] two

weeks from the time you receive this; and will almost immediately return and obtain working draughts and such farther instructions as may be necessary.
    It is Mr Latrobe’s decided opinion, & it is now mine that the building be of Stone; that the basement story of the old building be used; and that it be, of course, on Scite of foundation of the old.  This will save expense, but if the thing was new, it is the place.  In the center one way, and above 2/3 in depth; & on a ground some what rising.
                Yours,
                H H Brackenridge


You will see that Mr Latrobe contributes gratis exclusive of Clerks hire, the advantage of his skill in architecture which is noble & deserves the gratitude of   the public.


Hugh Henry Brackenridge to James Hamilton

            Philad.  May 22. 1803
Sir.    Latrobe the architect is decisively for Stone as the materials of the College building.  Bricks will rust as well as brick and have the appearance of age.  But this, in either, is with him no objection.  He says Painters in their drawings give even new buildings, gives the rust of Antiquity, To make them venerable; and in large buildings, and of a public nature it is especially becoming.
    But as to materials, he prefers Stone, as proper for a large Edifice giving it the Appearance of Strength.
    You will see his plan which is in my opinion an improvement of that suggested by ourselves, and his reasons prevail with me as to throwing the entry to the North.  In that the main front will be turned away from the main street, and the necessaries two, will be in a range with the center of the building respectable of one and half story.  The upper part may be used for pigeons. 

They may be placed at the distance of 50 or 75 feet the 1/3 or 1/2 of the length of the edifice from it, and covered from the View or at least obscured by a clump of trees.
    He has convinced me that a basement story of 6 feet above ground is necessary to give proportion to the elevation of the building and to give a proper elevation.  In the case with the advantage of 4 or 5 feet under ground, the Stewarts Apartments dining room, etc. will be in the basement story and supersede the necessity of other buildings.
    The defect of the Princeton basement story is the not being more than 2 or 3 feet above ground.  It is too much a Cellar, which produces Damp.  He is in favour of sheet iron for a rooff the expense of which is 1/3 more than Shingles.
    As the building need not be completed but gradually, the outward walls & the rooff first, These ought to be of the first consideration, and leave the expence of the whole out of the question.  Trust to future occasion for the whole.

Impressed with a strong Sense of importance of the plan which never can be mended, I have taken all pains to serve the institution in this particular.
    If the plan of Mr. Latrobe is adopted, he will furnish working plans to the utmost minuteness which will be of great advantage.
    I will be at home by the 6th of June, and assist with any advice it may be in my power to give.
                Yours.
                H H Brackenridge


[ Reading Room ] [ Chronicles ]