On April 2, 1904, the Phi Kappa Psi fraternity at Dickinson College in Carlisle, Pennsylvania purchased a house at 228 West High Street, immediately west of the President's House.  The three-story brick house had been built around the time of the Civil War, was the former family home of Abram Bosler, Dickinson College class of 1905 and a member of Phi Kappa Psi.

In 1925 the house underwent major renovations that included the addition of a larger porch and large white pillars that reached to the third story. The fraternity resided in this house until 1963 when the house was sold to the College and razed. Phi Kappa Psi then moved into Quad 9 (now Wilson Hall) of the Fraternity Quadrangle.